Monday 16 October 2017

Social media research, ‘personal ethics’, and the Ethics Ecosystem

Gabrielle Samuel: Research Fellow Lancaster University / Research Associate, King’s College London.  Research interests: research ethics, ethical and social issues surrounding innovative biotechnologies; social media ethics; qualitative research.
Gemma Derrick: Lecturer, Department of Educational Research, Lancaster University. Research interests: Research evaluation, Qualitative research, Group/committee decision-making. 
Ethics review may seem overly bureaucratic to some, but in this blog we argue that a more researcher-committee collaborative process, rather than a gatekeeper ‘tick-box’ role, may help with navigating the ‘ethics ecosystem’ when using new research tools such as social media (SM) data.
The ethics ecosystem exists as an inter-related membership of academic bodies that, when fully functional, acts to reinforce a high-level of ethical behaviour from researchers, and to guard against academic misconduct.  Specifically, this ethics ecosystem can be described as all the individuals (researchers), organisations (research institutions/research ethics committees (RECs)) and external bodies (publishing houses, funding bodies, professional associations) which promote ethically responsible research behaviour in the academy. Ordinarily, the academy’s ethics ecosystem works well due to a shared understanding of what ethically responsible research behaviour is. However, this system breaks down when new ideas, methods or approaches are introduced to its members, and each player interprets and enforces theses ideals of ethical behaviour differently.  This forces each member to re-examine concepts previously thought to be set in ethical stone.  Such is the case of SM research.
Currently this system is failing SM research
Our research has spoken to members at all levels of the ethics ecosystem; researchers using SM data, research ethics committee members, universities, funding bodies, publishing houses and journal Editors, and we found that members possessed inconsistent understandings of ethics applicable to the use of SM in research.  There were different interpretations of the established ethical notions of consent (should we ask for it? shouldn’t we? when and how should we?) and privacy (how, or even should, SM users’ data be protected, and to what degree?); some members viewed SM data as ‘fair game’, while others were more cautious; and only some shouldered responsibility to protect SM users’ perceived privacy. What was lacking was an overarching understanding reinforced by a larger governance body as a mechanism to fuel a wider, community-led understanding about ethical conduct (and misconduct) towards SM research.
At the research level of the ecosystem, researchers’ were monitoring their own decisions about how best to act ethically. However, when left to their own devices this over-reliance on subjective monitoring of behaviour risks the development of a form of “personal ethics”, which would be different for each researcher within this ecosystem;
Interviewer: Are there any guidelines that you follow in your own research?
Researcher: It’s my guidelines. Everybody has their own definition of ethics…. 
This became dangerous when the acceptability of these decisions were related to how strongly researchers justify them, rather than being dependent on conduct checks and balances available by a wider, community-led ethical understanding of SM research;
You’ve got to develop the sense of what's right…then put that across and make your case’
The differing interpretations of personal ethics dovetailed at the institutional level of the ecosystem, when researchers had to, or chose to submit their research proposal to a REC for consideration. Committee members, as actors in this level of the ecosystem, spoke about their lack of experience in reviewing this type of research simply because so few proposals are submitted (due to the differing researcher interpretations of whether ethical review was required). As such REC judgements of ethical conduct relied heavily on researchers’ justifications of ethical decision-making within the application;
We…sometimes make different decisions even for projects that look pretty similar. It’s how they build up their case doing that particular project 
The same held true for other members of the ethics ecosystem, such as the Journal editors and, by extension, peer-reviewers.
To summarise, what does this wide disagreement around SM research mean for the ethics ecosystem? After all, there is nothing wrong with ethical norms being driven by researchers’ different subjective justifications of their personal ethics a.k.a ethical pluralism. However, for SM research, and similar new research tools, reliance on researchers’ justifications of ethical behaviour can be dangerous as it risks leaving important ethical decisions in limbo, and allows for ethically problematic research to fall between the cracks.
What is needed is more governance within the ethics ecosystem.  Only then can enough checks and balances exist to ensure best practice, promote a shared understanding of SM research ethics, and provide necessary audits to protect against scientific misconduct.
One step towards this is to require researchers to submit for ethics review to provide an extra layer of scrutiny. More importantly, it provides REC members with the tacit knowledge necessary to act as this larger arbitrator of ethical conduct for SM research.

22 comments:

  1. Great blog! I really love how it is easy on my eyes and the information are well written. I am wondering how I might be notified whenever a new post has been made.
    I have subscribed to your feed which really should do the trick! Have a nice day! We provide you Web Development Company Chicago support and
    service.

    Web Design Chicago
    Web Development Company Chicago

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have found this information to be extremely valuable which will definitely help others. Thanks for the article. Great!!
    Looking For Website Developer

    ReplyDelete
  3. Buy instagram likes Affordable Package
    Instagram Followers, Buy Instagram Likes, Facebook Likes, YouTube Views, SoundCloud Plays, Twitter and Vine Followers. Super fast delivery! starting at $0.99 only!.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for sharing valuable information nice post,I enjoyed reading this post.

    ดูหนังออนไลน์

    ReplyDelete
  5. Buy authentic instagram followers
    Instagram Followers, Buy Instagram Likes, Facebook Likes, YouTube Views, SoundCloud Plays, Twitter and Vine Followers. Super fast delivery! starting at $0.99 only!.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Fajartoto like to read your article because it really helps me. Thank you for sharing this post with us.
    Togel Online
    Prediksi Hongkong

    ReplyDelete
  7. Good post but I was wondering if you could write a litte more on this subject? I’d be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Appreciate it! niche related backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi, I just gone through this blog, the information was really very valuable, would love to see more from you. i have also plenty of the same kind of content You can explore my blog by clicking the link below
    delhi institute of digital marketing
    digital marketing training in delhi
    internet marketing course in delhi
    digital marketing training institute in delhi
    delhi institute of internet marketing

    ReplyDelete
  9. This is a truly good site post. Not too many people would actually, the way you just did. I am really impressed that there is so much information about this subject that have been uncovered and you’ve done your best, with so much class. If wanted to know more about green smoke reviews, than by all means come in and check our stuff. im academy trading reviews

    ReplyDelete
  10. If we truly need a pizza or a shovel odds are we may just use Goggle and contact the company located closest to us. On another hand, if we needed a good Dentist or accountant or a developer for the new restaurant we are preparing to launch than we will put a little more care into our selection. Odds are that individuals will ask someone with a great smile or profit the bank or a well-designed business. We would like someone we feel we could trust - and to find the individuals we go to your network. Kennected

    ReplyDelete
  11. I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often. stephen twomey

    ReplyDelete
  12. Call Girls in Hyderabad We need genuine people looking Call Girls in Banjara Hills
    and Vip single female locanto escorts service in Hyderabad Independent Escort Thank you very much for visiting Delhi NCR. Call Girls in Gurgaon


    Split Ac Repair in Delhi NCR. Ac Repair Service in Rohini
    Fridge, Window Ac, Split Ac Gas Filling service in Delhi All Electronic Machine Repair Samsung, Lg Ac Installation near me
    AC Repair Service in Dwarka Delhi

    Hitech City Call Girls AC Repair, Led tv repair best technician
    lg Led tv repair service center near me LED TV Service Center in Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  13. Delhi Escorts Offer The Safest Escort Services To Clients
    Make Your Evening Special And Romantic With Hot Delhi Escorts In Budget And Get 100% Physical Satisfaction. People Who Have Not Made Any Physical Relationship Yet Have A Golden Opportunity To Open Up And Become Extroverted Now. Booking Open Now Pick Up Your Phone Text Us.
    Delhi Escorts
    Delhi Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  14. It's very informative post for everyone. Thanks for sharing
    Manoj Kumar Jain

    ReplyDelete
  15. Delhi escorts have many dimensions for different people. For the lost lover, they bring fresh baths to calm their depressed heart. They give them a true girlfriend experience that helps them forget about their painful past. They are happy and can find an enjoyable presence.

    ReplyDelete
  16. pg slot99 เกมสล็อต ค่าย พีจี ถือเป็นค่าย เกมสล็อตออนไลน์ มาแรงตลอดหลายปี ที่ผ่านมา เปิดตัวใหม่ มาใน รูปแบบเกมสล็อต 3D มีเกมสล็อต น่าสนุกตื่นเต้น ที่นักเดิมพัน ในการเข้าเล่น

    ReplyDelete