Thursday, 12 April 2018

Rumours, mis- and disinformation in divided societies: Twitter and the Ardoyne parade dispute


Dr. Paul Reilly is Senior Lecturer in Social Media & Digital Society at the University of Sheffield. His research focuses on the use of social media by citizens to share acts of sousveillance, as well as how digital media can be utilised to promote better community relations in divided societies such as Northern Ireland. His work  has been published in a number of journals including First Monday, Information, Communication & Society, New Media & Society, Policy and Internet and Urban Studies. He is currently completing his second monograph on Social media and contentious politics in Northern Ireland (contracted with Manchester University Press). @PaulJReilly
 
The rerouting of a contentious Orange Order parade away from the Ardoyne shops in North Belfast would lead to four consecutive nights of “animalistic” violence by loyalist protesters in July 2013. Despite the seeming inevitability of further violence, both the Orangemen and the Ardoyne residents were widely praised for the parade passing off without incident in July 2014. However, the 2015 parade would again be marred by violence, as loyalists faced off against PSNI officers who prevented the march from returning home via its traditional route. Having praised the behaviour of the Orange Order and residents a year earlier, Secretary of State Teresa Villiers described the attacks on police as disgraceful and accused the rioters of ‘damaging’ Northern Ireland.
 
This raised questions about what role, if any, social media played in helping escalate or de-escalate the tensions surrounding the contentious parade in 2014 and 2015. Previous research had suggested that the sharing of misinformation and disinformation (term used to describe the inadvertent and deliberate sharing of false information) had contributed to intercommunal violence in contested urban interface areas. Therefore, this study examined how users responded to rumours and disinformation that were circulated on Twitter. These issues were explored through a critical thematic analysis of tweets posted during two periods: 11th - 14th July 2014, and 12th - 15th 2015. A total of 7388 tweets tagged #Ardoyne were identified, 1,842 in 2014 and 5,546 in 2015. These tweets peaked at 7pm on the day of the Twelfth demonstrations in both years (see Figure 1). One explanation for this finding was that this spike in Twitter activity was the result of viewers of flagship television news programmes turning to social media to follow what was happening during the return leg of the parade. 



Figure 1: Tweets mentioning Ardoyne, 12th July 2014 and 13th July 2015
 
Tweeters move quickly to debunk rumours and disinformation
 
Rumours and disinformation appeared to have a very short life span in both corpora. This was particularly evident in the 2014 corpus, where there was some evidence to suggest that both loyalists and republicans were checking the veracity of claims made by each other on the microblogging site. Loyalists were accused of digitally altering pictures in order to portray the nationalist residents in a negative light. A picture of one of the protesters that had gathered outside the Ardoyne shops began to circulate on Twitter shortly after 7.30pm on 12th July. The placard they held aloft contained a mock-up road sign indicating that the Orange Order was not welcome in the area. One tweeter suggested that this was evidence of the intolerance of republicans and highlighted the ‘unlawful’ nature of the protests against the march. Twitter users immediately appeared sceptical of the authenticity of this image. Visual evidence suggesting that this was a photoshopped image was shared on Twitter within a few minutes. The original image showed the protester at a peaceful Christian protest at the shop fronts with his placard proclaiming “Love Thy Neighbour”, rather than the anti-Orange Order slogan that had featured in the doctored image. This was corroborated by an image of the same scene, taken and shared on Twitter by BBC NI journalist Kevin Sharkey a few hours earlier. Many tweeters accused the loyalist responsible for sharing the photoshopped image of spreading lies about what was happening on the ground at Ardoyne.
 
 
Tweet from BBC NI reporter Kevin Sharkey used to discredit photoshopped image, July 2014.

A similar theme emerged in relation to the Ardoyne parade and counter-demonstrations in July 2015. Images taken from many different vantage points were used to support claims and counter-claims about the incident in which an Orangeman drove his vehicle into a crowd of nationalist residents, seriously injuring a 16 year old girl. West Belfast UPRG was one of several accounts to share reports that the republicans had attacked a car, with no reference to the attempted murder of the residents in attendance (see Figure 2). It should be noted that one of these tweeters had been responsible for the photoshopped image of the ‘Love Thy Neighbour’ placard the previous year. Elsewhere, there was much speculation about whether the victim had been in or was trapped under the vehicle. The coverage of the incident by the Belfast Telegraph was questioned for its headline referring to a ‘crash’ rather than an incident of attempted murder of the injured teenager.  Within a few minutes of the incident, first reported by reporters such as the BBC’s Chris Buckler at 7.43pm, the PSNI confirmed that the girl had been injured and that the driver had been arrested at the scene. It would be a further two hours before local MLAs such as Gerry Kelly and the PSNI Chief Constable George Hamilton would confirm that her injuries were not life threatening.

Figure 2: Loyalist counter-narrative about teenage girl hit by car in Ardoyne, 13 July 2015.
 
There was one incident in particular that illustrated how citizens were using Twitter to prevent the spread of rumours and misinformation that might incite violence during the contentious North Belfast parade. One user tweeted a rumour that he had heard from an acquaintance, suggesting that a deal had been put in place that would see the return leg of the parade proceed via its traditional route past the Ardoyne shops. This tweet, shared a few days before the Twelfth, was only shared three times but clearly had the potential to raise tensions in Ardoyne. The same user would acknowledge that this information was untrue and apologise for spreading false information in a tweet posted on the morning of the 13th July 2015. Clearly it is difficult to tell how many tweeters may have seen the original tweet, or how they responded to this false information.
 
Twitter as tool to empower citizens to counter mis- and disinformation?
 
Twitter did not appear to provide the shared space that is required for reconciling the differences between loyalists and the nationalist residents’ groups in Ardoyne. The same group of highly engaged users dominated both of these Twitter streams, with tweets from the news media the most retweeted and the most likely to reach users across the sectarian divide. There were no signs of the rational debate and deliberation that would appear to be needed in order to resolve the Ardoyne parade dispute. However, Twitter might not be the most appropriate platform to facilitate intergroup contact and discussions about polarising issues such as parades and related protests. The complexities of such issues are unlikely to be explored through the exchange of messages that are restricted to just 140 characters. A related concern would be the representativeness of the Twitter users who engage in such online debates. Recent research has suggested that social media perpetuates the “spiral of silence,” whereby people only speak in public about certain policy issues if they believe that their views are shared by others. Nevertheless, Twitter’s most significant contribution to peacebuilding in Northern Ireland might lie in its empowerment of citizens to correct rumours and disinformation. The relatively short lifespan of these rumours, not to mention the lack of mainstream media coverage they received, illustrated how effectively tweeters corrected disinformation during this period. It is reasonable to presume that this activity helped calm some tensions between these antagonistic groups, particularly in light of the negative impact upon community relations that rumours spread on social media had during the 2013 union flag protests. However, the violence seen in 2015 clearly demonstrates how the use of Twitter to correct rumours, mis- and disinformation may be insufficient to prevent the outbreak of violence in interface areas.

41 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. We are one of the most trusted
    Android Mobile App Development and IOS application development to meet your business complex requirement through offshore world.
    Do you have project and want to discuss with us ?
    We can assist you in Web Application Development, Mobile App development, Games Development & Emerging Technology.

    ReplyDelete

  3. WOW Thanks for sharing I learned new information from your article, i want to share some intresting things like.Seo Company in Bhopal
    and web development bhopal

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Wow what a article i really enjoyed reading this i will come again to read, And you are looking for Hosting Services in india Please visit us We are Best Hosting Service Provider Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  5. EUMAXINDIA - Social media marketing is a Best technique that involves using social media websites such as face book, twitter, LinkedIn, Pinterest and Google+ for promoting products/services in Chennai.

    Social Media Marketing Company in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for sharing such a nice post. Blue Astral

    ReplyDelete
  7. Asian Dating Social Join today to meet ew people and have fun.
    You will meet a lot of interesting people here. We make ASIAN Dating much easier.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hackova Digi Media is the one of the best Digital Marketing service providers in Hyderabad. We have a team of experts in all areas of Digital Marketing. Hackova Digi Media provides Search Engine Optimization (SEO), Search Engine Marketing (SEM), Social Media Marketing (SMM), and E-mail Marketing services at affordable prices.
    http://www.hackovadigimedia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Buy instagram Followers Affordable Package Buy Instagram Followers, Buy Instagram Likes, Facebook Likes, YouTube Views, SoundCloud Plays, Twitter and Vine Followers. Super fast delivery! starting at $0.99 only!.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for the informative article. This is one of the best resources I have found in quite some time. Nicely written and great info. I really cannot thank you enough for sharing.

    Herbalife Center in Chennai
    Nutritionclub in Chennai
    Weight Loss in Chennai
    Weight Gain in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  11. On their official website finding overall information could be potential. Bhopal Escort Service is going to be around 24/7 all of you want to do is just give a call once you want them. Charming model give you amazing joy with no uncertainty.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Actual descriptions, private consideration, honesty, discretion and esteem will be exactly what my own value customers get to understand and assume out of a top quality independent Escort Service In Jaipur . My job is always to exhibit the very top quality escorts assistance in Bangalore for customers who have whole visibility and discretion and elegance.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Replies
    1. Professional SEO Services in Faridabad! We offer free consultation for all businesses. Give us a call today to learn more about our SEO Faridabad and how we will rank you on the 1st page of Google!

      Delete
  14. Thank for your very good article! i always enjoy & read the post you are sharing!

    ดูหนังออนไลน์

    ReplyDelete
  15. buy facebook accounts pva Thanks for the informative article. This is one of the best resources I have found in quite some time.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hadoop concepts, Applying modelling through R programming using Machine learning algorithms and illustrate impeccable Data Visualization by leveraging on 'R' capabilities.With companies across industries striving to bring their research and analysis (R&A) departments up to speed, the demand for qualified data scientists is rising.
    data science training in bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  17. VEMLIDY ( Tenofovir Alafenamide 25 mg ) used to treat the HBV (chronic hepatitis B virus ) and HIV in the adult. Its Uses, Price, Cost,Side Effects.Hepbest 25mg

    ReplyDelete
  18. Instagram Followers, Buy Instagram Likes, Facebook Likes, YouTube Views, SoundCloud Plays, Twitter and Vine Followers. Super fast delivery! starting at $0.99 only!.
    Buy instagram Followers Affordable Package

    ReplyDelete
  19. definite. apart from that, i'm no longer particular i might want to characterize issues as unusual and exciting. it is all extra style of surreal.

    buy soundcloud followers

    ReplyDelete
  20. Really Good Useful & informative blog. Really like to read this blog. great article.The blog was really nice, I really found out about a lot of Awesome content. you can check these blog to get different types of knowledge.
    anybloginfo
    anybloginfo
    anyblognews
    universitycolleague
    Interviewgyan
    bestsites
    socialmediaupdates
    makemoneyasfreelance

    ReplyDelete
  21. I visited your blog and read your all posts very carefully you are sharing good posts actually I am looking for
    click here

    ReplyDelete
  22. BUY YOUTUBE ACCOUNTS REDDIT

    →→ buy youtube verified accounts that follow
    Buy top quality YouTube Accounts From A trusted provider with quick Delivery!

    ReplyDelete
  23. ECIR - we are always in touch and always ready to help our customers. 6 years of experience in Internet marketing with quality Instagram likes.

    ReplyDelete
  24. ECIR - we are always in touch and always ready to help our customers. 6 years of experience in Internet marketing and providing services for buy Instagram likes and facebook likes.

    ReplyDelete
  25. call the escort office Bhopal escorts" and not to Organize to itself a wonderful voyage through the city joined by a woman, consummate in all regards, ready to keep the discussion on any point Solid auto, costly suit, jazzy watch and an incredible partner - a number in which there is no infringement of rationale.

    ReplyDelete

  26. Meet stunning Indian & Pakistani girls in Dubai now. simply arrived to Dubai to offer her non-public offerings. in case you are seeking out a chic girl who can talk fluently in English and may obey your every order right away, then we've got an ideal women for you.Student escorts in dubai She has all the skills to launch all of your sexual frustrations or tiredness. thy Are give you sweet kissing enjoy that's sincerely unforgettable and for all time revel in. She offers masses of ultra horny offerings like, Anal, GFE, Golden shower and Outcall Incalls. Model escorts in dubai

    ReplyDelete

  27. Meet stunning Indian & Pakistani girls in Dubai now. simply arrived to Dubai to offer her non-public offerings. in case you are seeking out a chic girl who can talk fluently in English and may obey your every order right away, then we've got an ideal women for you.Student escorts in dubai She has all the skills to launch all of your sexual frustrations or tiredness. thy Are give you sweet kissing enjoy that's sincerely unforgettable and for all time revel in. She offers masses of ultra horny offerings like, Anal, GFE, Golden shower and Outcall Incalls. Model escorts in dubai

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thank you very much for for your great information. It really makes me happy and I am satisfied with the arrangement of your post. You are really a talented person I have ever seen. I will keep following you forever. If you have time you can check this site and give me suggestion.
    Hotel Bedding Supplies

    ReplyDelete